Sounds simple enough. Why can't I just say 'No comment' and leave it at that?

Here's why. Let me paint a scenario you don’t want to experience.

How 'no comment' can hurt you

Your phone rings. You pick it up.
“Jeff Jones.”
“Mike Williams here from DXTV. We’ve just heard about your problem with the—”
“No comment.” Click.

That night, on the six o’clock news you see Mike Williams, standing in front of your office saying, “We put those allegations to the manager—that his building is a legitimate business by day and a mafia laundering operation by night. He refused to comment.” To the public audience, perceived unwillingness to talk = guilty as sin.

Using 'no comment' effectively

There’s nothing wrong with not commenting—often you must not comment, perhaps because it's still under investigation, or for legal reasons—what’s important is that you always say why you can't comment, and your tone and demeanour must indicate your normal willingness to be open when appropriate. It just happens that this time, it isn't.

A typical response might be, “I’m sorry, I can’t talk about that because there has been an arrest or it’s under investigation.” Or “No it wouldn’t be right to comment on that, it wouldn’t be fair to either side until the investigation is complete.”

One more point.

When a broadcasting reporter goes to an experienced interviewee and asks for comment the reply is very often like this. “No, I can’t comment on that because it’s still under investigation… do you want to record me saying so?” The recorder or camera is switched on, the question asked again, and the same answer given. “I can’t comment on that because...”



Interested in a workshop on media skills for your team?

About Michael Brown

michael semiformal 460x300

Michael is a senior trainer with Skillset, based in Christchurch.

He is a leading authority on training in presentation and news media skills in New Zealand. He has special expertise in how to present emotionally-charged topics to challenging audiences. Michael has trained thousands of New Zealanders and worked with people who speak on behalf of some of the country's largest organisations.

Michael is a prolific author and his books on speaking and working with the media are in their fourth editions.

Speaking Easy: how to speak to your audiences with confidence and authority

Media Easy: how to handle the news media with confidence and authority

One of Michael's books is about his family's adventures sailing in the Pacific.

Ready for more? See the archive

Interested in training in presentation skills?

We can help your presenters engage their audiences – whether they are speaking at major conferences, presenting to the community or colleagues, or speaking up at a meeting.

Learn more

Interested in training in media skills?

Our experienced media trainers can show your spokespeople how to work with the media so that everyone benefits.

Learn more

Register for The Skillset Brief

Tips, advice and insights from our specialists.

It's not a newsletter. There's no news and it's not about us - just ideas you can use.

We send them out every few weeks.

Register for The Skillset Brief